Having not managed to see Gomorra in the cinema in 2008, I jumped at the chance of make it one of the first films I saw on the big screen in 2009. For those of you that don’t know anything about the film, its plot weaves together five stories of various Neapolitans and their involvement with the Camorra. Gomorra won the Grand Prix at the Cannes Film Festival in 2008 and was chosen by Italy as its contender for the Best Foreign Language Film at the 81st Academy Awards. However, even though I enjoyed the film, I came out the screening thinking more about the subtitles more than anything else.
Visually Gomorra is soaked in the bright sunlight of Naples and is a film that’s aesthetically striking, with its vibrant palette of yellows and whites. However, I have to question the choice to put the subtitles also in white! There were times during the film where I lost minutes of dialogue due to the white subtitles being washed out on stretches of beach or camouflaged by white washed walls. I know traditionally subtitles are always in white and usually it’s the right colour to use, as white stands out against the majority of other colours, but does this always have to be the case? Surely someone watched the subtitled version of Gomorra before it was released and if so, did they not think at any point – “these subtitles are really hard to read!”
In a Foreign language film subtitles are a necessity, not an extra and in my opinion they are as important as the audio itself. So why isn’t more care and attention paid to the poor old neglected subtitled?
Don’t get me wrong, not every film underestimates the power of the subtitle, there are some shining examples out there that show how a film can use the subtitle to it’s advantage.
Night Watch (Nochnoy Dozor) with it’s ‘in the print’ subtitles is one such example. I remember seeing Timur Bekmambetov’s film at the cinema and just being totally blown away by the time and effort that had been spent on the subtitles. Instead of just using static lines of text for the viewer to read, the director made the choice to have text that interacts with his film and adds to the visuals (instead of distracting!). Night Watch’s subtitles appear all over the screen, come from behind pillars and are occasionally even made of blood. “We thought of the subtitles as another character in the film, another way to tell the story.“, why can’t all directors feel like this?
Another film that takes full advantage of the subtitle is Bienvenue Chez les Ch’tis, a movie that’s charm and humour largely comes from the language used by the Northern characters in the film and something that could’ve easily been lost in translation. Thankfully though the subtitles transfer the humour excellently and instead of taking away from the film, it’s in the subtitles where most of the humour can be found.
So please take note all directors and subtitlers, enough film-goers already use the subtitle as an excuse not to watch a foreign language film (I hate hearing the “it’s like reading” excuse), give your subtitles the love and care they deserve.
Great article, really raises some interesting points on this tricky task.
At the European Independent Film Festival, we receive films from all over the world and in many different languages – French, Portuguese, Hebrew, Hungarian, Polish, Russian, Italian, Spanish, Icelandic, English and even Aussie (*do* they qualify as speaking English in the land down under?). This ultimately raises the following question: how can filmmakers and subtitles work together to appeal to the international audience?
The ECU 2010 Official Selection will be subtitled as follows: English films will be subtitled in French, French films subtitled in English and all other foreign language films will be subtitled in English. We believe this is the best way for the international audience and jury to watch, appreciate and get maximum ejoyment from the ÉCU 2010 Official Selection. With the Official Selection announcment on the 15th February, and the festival one month later, competing directors need to start thinking about how to address the subtitle situation if they have not done so already.
Who knows, maybe our directors will use this article and it’s advice as inspiration to breathe new life into a project, which at this point, they’re sick of staring at.
I’m glad to know someone else feels my pain and more importantly, shares my concerns.
I’ve always been a huge fan of ‘world’ cinema and can’t imagine how my experience of films would have differed if I’d only watched English language films throughout my life (my Greek girlfriend can confirm how poor my multi-lingual skills are).
However, I really can’t count the number of times I’ve felt let down by the lack of care and effort that has gone into a films subtitling. White text on a white background, spelling mistakes and bad timing are problems that occur all too often for my liking. If you’re distributing a ‘foreign’ language film, surely the one thing you’d check is the subtitles, they’re pretty damn important!
Ultimately though, the worst problem I’ve had with a subtitled film is when I bought a copy of Harry, He’s here to Help and the subtitles didn’t work at all. It was almost enough to make me take French lessons…almost.
This really needs to be disseminated to the Directors. As a foreign film fan, I agree it can be frustrating to not be able to read the subtitles. That said, I am not sure I want someone to get too creative on the film, and the words start to take away from the visual creation of the original film content. Readable but not dominate.
I really liked your advice to directors to give their subtitles the love and care that they deserve. My son loves films. So much so that he quit his job to try out freelance videography. He tells me that he wants to enroll in a film program. I’m all for it so I’ll be sure to share this article with him so he can consider getting a professional transcription service to help him out with the subtitles.
Thanks for sharing this with your son Kit. It’s great to hear that you like the piece and that you’re encouraging his progression as a filmmaker. Hopefully we’ll see his work on DN in the near future.